What do the following three events have in common: the three-judge
panel of the 9th Circuit Court of Appeals trying to throw out
the California recall election, the Dixie Chicks' announcement
that they're leaving country music and the continued French
refusal to assist America's efforts in Iraq?
The answer is that they're all the products
of an increasingly bitter, desperate, but determined elite,
whose exploits are
the subject of a fascinating new book by Laura Ingraham, "Shut
Up and Sing."
We used to think of the elites as the monied class who went
to all the celebrated schools. Ingraham demonstrates the obsolescence
of that description and explains that today's elites are defined
not by their economic status, but by a common state of mind.
They can be recognized by their allegiances -- for Harvard
over the Heartland -- rather than their pocketbooks and pedigree.
With wit and clarity Ingraham provides the salient characteristics
of the elites, in general, before going on to explain the various
subcategories of the specimen, including the mainstream media,
academia, the cultural elite, the world citizens' lobby and
the activist judiciary. She depicts them through their own
words and actions rather than her subjective opinions about
them, which she provides in due course.
The elites -- according to the elites -- are
brilliant, they eschew moral absolutes, disdain religion,
particularly the
Christian religion, and they hail (largely) from places outside "fly-over" country
and look down on those inside it. They are mostly anti-military
and have a paternalistic attitude toward the protected categories
-- race, sex and otherwise -- and believe that without themselves,
these groups will flounder.
The elites are committed globalists who are
more likely to defer to the United Nations than promote America's
national
interests, and their natural political home is the Democratic
Party. But according to Ingraham, "the GOP has its share
of elites, too."
Ingraham also explores how the elites gained
prominence in our society, properly noting that their ascendancy
wasn't the
result of a single event. "It has been building, morphing,
and spreading for a very long time." Quite intriguing
is her observation that "Most would think that it all
begin in the 1960s, but surprisingly enough, today's poisonous
elites have their roots in the antebellum South." How
can that be when they tend to have a sneering contempt for
that very region of this country, along with the other areas
that comprise Al Gore's red states? She answers the question
in Chapter 2.
Ingraham also has her finger on the pulse of the movement
to expunge Christianity from America's public square and its
popular culture. She does an excellent job summarizing this
dangerous and disturbing trend.
One group Ingraham takes to task is "the judicial elite." Many,
mostly political liberals, defend the practice of activist
judges in interpreting the Constitution through the prism of
their own subjective preferences rather than the original intent
of the Constitution. They harbor an elitist attitude that essentially
says that we know better than the pedestrian legislature and
the body politic what is good for America and we're going to
interpret the Constitution as we see fit. The end justifies
the means.
A recent example of this was the radical three judge panel
of the Ninth U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals throwing out the
California recall election, only to be overruled -- amazingly
-- by the full Court.
Ingraham also exposes the "tolerance" and "diversity" peddlers
in our universities and public school system who betray their
hypocrisy in reserving tolerance for those with whom they agree
and disrespect for all others.
Ingraham's book is not, however, merely a laundry list of
offenses committed by the elite. It analyzes their inner workings,
their motivations, their agenda and their progress. As importantly,
it offers a prescription for the ordinary Joes and Sallies
among us to fight back.
She urges that conservatives take on the elites head-on in
the market place of ideas, where she believes we can prevail
if we maintain the courage of our convictions and refuse to
cower to the intimidation tactics of the elites.
"Shut Up and Sing" -- an admonition to outspoken
Hollywood and other entertainment types-- offers a truly insightful
and learned perspective on modern society. It is a comprehensive
and devastating critique of the elites whose stature and credibility
will diminish in direct proportion to the number of Ingraham's
fine book in circulation.