Cold war liberals still don't get it
March 1, 2003
Some have
suggested the conservatives' hawkishness toward Saddam Hussein
can be traced to their search, since the end of the Cold War,
for new bogeymen to replace the Soviet Communists as the focus
of their aggressive propensities. They're wrong.
It is not
the conservative psyche that needs analysis. Conservatives were
right in the Cold War -- so right that liberals are pretending
they were with us all along -- and they are right about Iraq.
It is leftists who need to account for their consistently disgraceful
positions throughout the Cold War and into the War on Terror.
That's where
Mona Charen's "Useful Idiots, How Liberals Got it Wrong in
the Cold War and Still Blame America First" comes in. In
this scholarly, yet page-turning read, Mona finally brings liberals
to account, not just for their behavior during the Cold War, but
because they're at it again. With meticulous research and trenchant
analysis, she irrefutably documents the common threads tying yesterday's
war protestors to today's with a clarity that only Mona's crisp
pen can deliver, making the book historically instructive and
currently relevant.
Book reviews
are difficult because you can only provide a snapshot of a book's
voluminous material. But let me just share a number of uncanny
similarities between the anti-Vietnam War left and today's war
protesting throngs that I gleaned from the pages of this excellent
book.
-- Liberals
have never admitted their error in misjudging the Communists,
even after the slaughter of 2,000,000 Cambodians when we exited
Indochina. Worse, they've even rewritten history to include themselves
as Cold Warriors. Today, they are at it again with an equal degree
of sanctimony and a comparable dearth of credibility.
-- Liberals
were more contemptuous of Cold Warriors than they were of the
Soviets; today, they are more contemptuous of President Bush and
conservatives than Saddam Hussein.
-- As such
they protested in the streets against America (then and now),
but not against the murderous Soviet or Iraqi regimes.
-- Their anti-war
protests were not just about the Vietnam War, and they're not
just about Iraq. In both cases they have decried and despised
America for everything from its "materialism" to its
"militarism."
-- The protestors
in both cases have been "Useful Idiots" -- useful to
the Soviets and to Saddam. With the devastating information in
the book as to their culpability concerning the Cold War, however,
one wonders whether at this point "idiot" is too charitable
a term. But I won't quarrel with the title.
-- The protestors
of yesteryear denied sympathy for the Communists, all the while
romanticizing Soviet life and Castro's Cuba. Today, they insist
they have contempt for the "despicable" Saddam, yet
appear utterly unwilling to back up those words with action.
-- In the
sixties, they leveled outlandish, conspiracy-based allegations
that America was in it for South Vietnam's minerals. Today, they
say it's the Iraqi oil fields, even though we had those for the
taking in 1991 and allowed Saddam to keep them.
Mona even
answers those -- then and now -- who claim it is outrageous to
accuse war opponents of being anti-American. That's not what Mona
and other conservatives are saying. Indeed, Mona readily admits
that "a reasonable and credible case could have been made,
and here and there was, that sending ground troops to Vietnam
was neither prudent nor necessary." But most of the protestors
weren't making that reasonable case; that's not what they were
about. Too often their efforts were "dishonorable and dishonest,"
and their "willful blindness to the reality of the Communist
enemy was a grave moral lapse."
Similarly,
most conservatives would agree that a reasonable case can be made
to oppose the war against Iraq, and by no means are all who oppose
it guilty of the attitude and behavior Mona describes in her book.
But a good number of them are, and they are of the same ideological
blood as their Vietnam-protesting and Cold-War-denying predecessors,
and have the same egg of culpability and shame on their faces.
You will want
to add this book to your library. You'll find that you don't have
to wait hundreds of years to forget lessons of history -- just
a generation or less can erase memories. But books like this remove
the erasers. You'll be glad you bought it.
|